Thursday, November 12, 2026

Book Review: Nightmare Alley

 William Lindsay Gresham's Nightmare Alley was published in 1946 and has seen two movie adaptions. At about only 250 pages, it's a brisk read that can be completed in a weekend. But this book's psychological impact will stay with you long after you finish reading. The title refers to a recurring dream that the book's protagonist, Stan Carlisle, has haunting him. In the dream, he feels he's being chased down a long nightmare alley where the buildings ominously close in on him. He's running from something, and the thing that's chasing him can be any number of things; his feelings of abandonment from his mother, his greed, his guilt over the death of his mentor, etc. But Stan realizes that everyone has their own nightmare alley, and that he can exploit it to become rich. Ominously he also realizes that the geek, a performer who bites the heads off chickens and that is practically enslaved by the carnival, is running from sobriety too. 

In his excellent introduction, Nick Toshces argues that it's impossible to view Nightmare Alley as a morality tale about a grifter getting what he deserves. The novel takes place in a world where morality doesn't exist at all. The novel's setting also has a more ancient connotation. Historically, the carnival represented a brief time where the world could be turned upside down. Peasants could make fun of kings and bishops during a carnival, under the assumption that every other time in the year they knew their place in the hierarchy. Gresham's carnival with its "sideshow freaks" is also outside the bounds of polite society. Even when Stan makes it to the top  with his mentalism act, the host at the party he performs in has her staff discreetly tell him not to mingle with the guests. Furthermore, fate is determined by tarot cards.

The carnival theme is also shown with Stan's love interest, Molly. She regularly performs with Stan in his mentalism act but breaks character when his biggest mark, Ezra Grindle, thinks that she's the resurrected ghost of his young love who died from a botched abortion. Her last appearance in the book shows her with her new husband and their new baby boy, who is named after her father. But this idyllic scene takes place not in a cozy middle class home, but at the racetrack. Her husband remarks that they may need to skip out again on their hotel bill. Gresham's happy endings fall outside the bounds of what many of his readers would deem moral.  

Gresham's novel is seedy, cruel, and a wonderfully nightmarish glimpse into a dark corner of the world. 

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

New Podcast Project

 I'm excited to say that I'm now a podcast host over at the New Books Network! I will host a show on their Historical Fiction channel. There's nothing more fun than talking to authors about their work. Stay tuned for new episodes coming soon! I was always told I have a face for radio :) 

Book Review: Nightmare Alley

 William Lindsay Gresham's Nightmare Alley was published in 1946 and has seen two movie adaptions. At about only 250 pages, it's a ...